All jobs

Upgrade a Click CLI to Click 8.2 and Later

Yes. An agent moves a Click CLI and its CliRunner tests across the Click 8.2 changes, runs the suite on old and new Click, compares real output and opens a PR.

Run this on RushOpens the console with this prompt ready to send, in a Project that has your repository.

What the agent does

The agent begins with what the project allows to be installed, since an unpinned dependency upgrades itself. In a CLI like simonw/files-to-prompt, pyproject.toml lists click with no version, declares requires-python = ">=3.8", and puts pytest in a test extra. .github/workflows/test.yml runs pip install '.[test]' and pytest on Python 3.9 through 3.13. PyPI's metadata shows what that means in practice: Click 8.1.8 supports Python 3.7 and later, while 8.2.0, 8.3.0 and the current 8.5.0 need Python 3.10. So the 3.9 job resolves an 8.1 release and the other four resolve the newest Click, and the same test file has to pass against both.

Then it reads the tests for what 8.2 changed in click.testing. Click's own source notes that the mix_stderr parameter of CliRunner was removed in 8.2, that Result.output became a separate stream with stdout and stderr interleaved in the order written, and that Result.stderr now always returns a string. In tests/test_files_to_prompt.py, test_binary_file_warning builds its runner with CliRunner(mix_stderr=False) and then asserts on result.stdout and result.stderr separately, to check that the skipped-file warning from click.echo(..., err=True) stays out of standard output. On new Click the constructor call is an error; on old Click, removing the argument makes result.stderr unavailable. The agent runs the suite in one environment per Click line to see both results before editing.

The fix depends on a decision, and the agent makes the conservative one and names the other. By default it keeps both lines working: a small helper in the test file builds the runner with mix_stderr=False where the installed Click accepts it and without it otherwise, and the assertions stay as they are. The alternative is to set click>=8.2 and raise requires-python to 3.10, which drops the 3.9 job and users on older interpreters; it describes that as a second option and does not take it unless the prompt says to.

Last it checks the command itself, because the test runner is not the only thing that moved. It reads Click's changelog from 8.1 to the current release and keeps the entries that touch what files_to_prompt/cli.py uses: a nargs=-1 argument of click.Path(exists=True), multiple=True options, one with default=[], boolean flags, version_option() and BadArgumentUsage. It installs the tool in both environments and runs the same invocations in each over the same directory: plain, --cxml, --markdown, -n, -o to a file, paths piped on stdin with and without --null, --help and --version. It then diffs the outputs.

Start it with one API call

POST https://api.phoenix.so/o/{org}/sessions with this body:

{
  "agent": "claude",
  "input": "Make this Click CLI and its tests work on current Click as well as the oldest Click the project still supports. Read pyproject.toml, the CI workflows, the CLI module and the whole test file first. From PyPI, find the Python floor of Click 8.1.x, 8.2.0 and the current release, and say which Click each Python version in the CI matrix resolves. Create one virtual environment per Click line, each on an interpreter that line supports, install the project with its test extra in both, and run pytest in both before changing anything; keep the output. Read Click's changelog from 8.1 to the current release and list the entries that affect what this code uses: CliRunner arguments, Result.output, stdout and stderr, nargs=-1 arguments, multiple options and their defaults, flags, version_option and usage errors. Fix the tests so they pass on both lines without weakening an assertion; where an API exists on only one line, use a small helper in the tests and say what it does. Do not pin or cap click and do not change requires-python; describe that option in the pull request instead. Change the CLI module only if a changelog entry requires it, and say which. Then install the command in both environments, run the same set of invocations in each against the same directory, including stdin input, file output, --help and --version, and diff the results. Open a pull request with both pytest runs before and after, the changelog entries you acted on, and the output comparison.",
  "resources": [
    {
      "url": "https://github.com/your-org/your-app"
    }
  ]
}
  1. Get an API key. In the console, open Settings, then API keys, and create a key for your org. Send it in the Authorization header as a Bearer token.
  2. Send the request. POST the body in request.json to https://api.phoenix.so/o/{org}/sessions, with your repository as the resources URL. The run starts in its own cloud sandbox.
  3. Read what came back. Follow the run on its live stream or wait for the run.completed webhook, then read the result and its trajectory.

What comes back

The pull request is mostly a test change. It carries the helper and the one call site that uses it, any other assertion that needed to move with its reason, and a change to the CLI module only where a changelog entry demanded one. pyproject.toml and the workflow are untouched under the default prompt. The description has a small table of Python version against the Click release it resolves, the four pytest runs (old and new Click, before and after), the changelog entries that applied with the line each one touched, and the diff of real command output between the two environments.

It closes with the choice it left open: keep supporting the 8.1 line, or raise the floors and delete the helper. Each option lists what changes in pyproject.toml and the CI matrix and who is affected. A reviewer checks that the warning test still proves the warning goes to standard error and nowhere else, that the output comparison includes the stdin and -o paths and that every difference in it is explained, and that nothing was pinned to make a red job green.

Run it on every failed test workflow

A CLI with an unpinned dependency finds out about a release when its own CI goes red, so that failure is the natural trigger. Create an automation in the Project that holds the repository with a github trigger on workflow_run.failure. The trigger puts the failed run after the saved prompt and fills in nothing, so the prompt says: read the failing job's log; if the traceback points into Click or its test runner, do the work on this page and open a pull request; if the cause is something else, end with one line naming it. CI runs from forks never fire it, and neither do bot senders.

A maintainer with a dozen small tools sends this body once per repository from a script instead, each with a request_id that is a UUID v5 of the repository's full name and the Click version being moved to, so sending the batch twice starts nothing new. Runs past the API key's concurrency limit wait as queued and start as slots free.

The use case this job follows, with its automation and trigger: Upgrade dependencies weekly.

Why run it on Rush?

The work is comparing two worlds, and a laptop usually has one. Seeing how the suite behaves on Click 8.1 and on the current release means two interpreters, two environments and the patience to run everything twice before and after. The agent sets both up in its sandbox, keeps all four test runs and the output diff in the run's record, and attaches them to the pull request, so the claim that nothing changed for users is backed by a comparison.

It also resists the two easy fixes. Capping click<8.2 turns the build green and leaves every user who installs the tool fresh on a version the tests no longer cover. Deleting the awkward assertion does the same with less honesty. The prompt forbids both, and the agent reports the trade-off for the maintainer to decide. Small tools tend to share an author and a layout, so the same request works across all of them, one run each.

Frequently asked questions

What breaks in tests when Click goes from 8.1 to 8.2?

The most common break is CliRunner(mix_stderr=False), because that parameter was removed. Tests that read result.output may also see standard error mixed in, in the order it was written. Code that reads result.stderr no longer needs the parameter, since it now always returns a string.

Why not just require Click 8.2 or later?

You can, and the pull request describes that option. It also means requiring Python 3.10, because that is the floor of Click 8.2.0 and of the current release. For a tool that still advertises older interpreters that is a breaking change for users, so the agent does not make it on its own.

Does my command's behaviour change for users?

That is what the output comparison is for. The agent runs the same invocations with old and new Click over the same files and diffs the results, including piped input and file output. Any difference is listed with the changelog entry that explains it.

Will it pin Click to a version?

No. The prompt says not to pin or cap it, because a library-style CLI installed with pip should accept the versions its users already have. If your project is an application with a lock file, say so and the agent updates the lock instead.

More Click jobs

More jobs like this: Upgrade dependencies weekly

Keep reading